« Modèle:Révision par des pairs » : différence entre les versions

Navigation interactive dans l’historique

[version non vérifiée]

← Modification précédente Modification suivante →

Contenu supprimé Contenu ajouté

VisuelWikicode

Intégrés

Version du 21 août 2008 à 21:19

Modèle:Proposed policy

Description

This template is used to advertise on an article's talk page the status of it being reviewed. It is designed to be simple to use, yet informative.

Use

{{peer reviewed
|revid=Revision ID
|copyright=Status
|newsworthy=Status
|verifiable=Status
|npov=Status
|style=Status
|reviewer=Your Username
|comments=Any Comments, ~~~~
|time=~~~~~}}

Revision ID is the number of the revision that has been reviewed. This is obtained from the History page of an article - it is the number after "oldid" in the current revision.

Status is pass for a passed section, or comments for a failed section.

Copyright: The reviewer should check that the text and images are not copyright infringement.
Newsworthiness: The reviewer should check that the article agrees with our content guide and is newsworthy.
Verifiability: The reviewer should check that all information in the article is fully sourced, (using multiple independent sources is strongly encouraged) or has adequate Original Reporting notes.
Neutral Point of View: The reviewer should check that all information in the article is written in a neutral and unbiased manner, with no editorial commentary/advocacy or unsourced opinion.
Style: The reviewer should check that all information in the article complies with our style guide (on dateline, grammar and spelling, "inverted pyramid" structure, tone, wikilinks, categories, headline... etc.)

Examples

A Passed article would look like:

{{peer reviewed|revid=12345|copyright=pass|newsworthy=pass|verifiable=pass|npov=pass|style=pass|reviewer=Skenmy|comments=A very good article! --~~~~|time=~~~~~}}

Modèle:Peer reviewed

A Failed article would look like:

{{peer reviewed|revid=12344|copyright=pass|newsworthy=pass|verifiable=Many claims are not backed up by sources|npov=Appears to be biased|style=pass|reviewer=Skenmy|comments=Otherwise a very good article. --~~~~|time=~~~~~}}

Modèle:Peer reviewed

@@ Ligne 1 : / Ligne 1 : @@
 <includeonly>{{ambox
-|image={{ #ifeq: {{{c}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{n}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{v}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{npov}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{s}}} | pass | [[Image:Artículo bueno.svg|40px]] | [[Image:Red x.svg|40px]] }} | [[Image:Red x.svg|40px]] }} | [[Image:Red x.svg|40px]] }} | [[Image:Red x.svg|40px]] }} | [[Image:Red x.svg|40px]] }}
+|image={{ #ifeq: {{{copyright}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{newsworthy}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{verifiable}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{npov}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{style}}} | pass | [[Image:Artículo bueno.svg|40px]] | [[Image:Red x.svg|40px]] }} | [[Image:Red x.svg|40px]] }} | [[Image:Red x.svg|40px]] }} | [[Image:Red x.svg|40px]] }} | [[Image:Red x.svg|40px]] }}
-|type={{ #ifeq: {{{c}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{n}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{v}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{npov}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{s}}} | pass | notice | content }} | content }} | content }} | content }} | content }}
+|type={{ #ifeq: {{{copyright}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{newsworthy}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{verifiable}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{npov}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{style}}} | pass | notice | content }} | content }} | content }} | content }} | content }}
-|text={{ #ifeq: {{{c}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{n}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{v}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{npov}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{s}}} | pass | {{peer reviewed/Passed|reviewer={{{reviewer}}}|comments={{{comments|No comments were left by the reviewer}}}|time={{{time}}}}} | {{peer reviewed/Failed|c={{{c}}}|n={{{n}}}|v={{{v}}}|npov={{{npov}}}|s={{{s}}}|reviewer={{{reviewer}}}|comments={{{comments}}}|time={{{time}}}}} }} | {{peer reviewed/Failed|c={{{c}}}|n={{{n}}}|v={{{v}}}|npov={{{npov}}}|s={{{s}}}|reviewer={{{reviewer}}}|comments={{{comments|No comments were left by the reviewer}}}|time={{{time}}}}} }} | {{peer reviewed/Failed|c={{{c}}}|n={{{n}}}|v={{{v}}}|npov={{{npov}}}|s={{{s}}}|reviewer={{{reviewer}}}|comments={{{comments}}}|time={{{time}}}}} }} | {{peer reviewed/Failed|c={{{c}}}|n={{{n}}}|v={{{v}}}|npov={{{npov}}}|s={{{s}}}|reviewer={{{reviewer}}}|comments={{{comments|No comments were left by the reviewer}}}|time={{{time}}}}} }} | {{peer reviewed/Failed|c={{{c}}}|n={{{n}}}|v={{{v}}}|npov={{{npov}}}|s={{{s}}}|reviewer={{{reviewer}}}|comments={{{comments|No comments were left by the reviewer}}}|time={{{time}}}}} }}
+|text={{ #ifeq: {{{copyright}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{newsworthy}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{verifiable}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{npov}}} | pass | {{ #ifeq: {{{style}}} | pass | {{peer reviewed/Passed|reviewer={{{reviewer}}}|comments={{{comments|No comments were left by the reviewer}}}|time={{{time}}}|revid={{{revid}}}}} | {{peer reviewed/Failed|c={{{copyright}}}|n={{{newsworthy}}}|v={{{verifiable}}}|npov={{{npov}}}|s={{{style}}}|reviewer={{{reviewer}}}|comments={{{comments}}}|time={{{time}}}|revid={{{revid}}}}} }} | {{peer reviewed/Failed|c={{{copyright}}}|n={{{newsworthy}}}|v={{{verifiable}}}|npov={{{npov}}}|s={{{style}}}|reviewer={{{reviewer}}}|comments={{{comments|No comments were left by the reviewer}}}|time={{{time}}}|revid={{{revid}}}}} }} | {{peer reviewed/Failed|c={{{copyright}}}|n={{{newsworthy}}}|v={{{verifiable}}}|npov={{{npov}}}|s={{{style}}}|reviewer={{{reviewer}}}|comments={{{comments}}}|time={{{time}}}|revid={{{revid}}}}} }} | {{peer reviewed/Failed|c={{{copyright}}}|n={{{newsworthy}}}|v={{{verifiable}}}|npov={{{npov}}}|s={{{style}}}|reviewer={{{reviewer}}}|comments={{{comments|No comments were left by the reviewer}}}|time={{{time}}}|revid={{{revid}}}}} }} | {{peer reviewed/Failed|c={{{copyright}}}|n={{{newsworthy}}}|v={{{verifiable}}}|npov={{{npov}}}|s={{{style}}}|reviewer={{{reviewer}}}|comments={{{comments|No comments were left by the reviewer}}}|time={{{time}}}|revid={{{revid}}}}} }}
 }}</includeonly><noinclude>{{proposed policy}}
 ==Description==
@@ Ligne 9 : / Ligne 9 : @@
 ==Use==
 <code><nowiki>{{</nowiki>peer reviewed</code><br />
-<code>|c='''''Status'''''</code><br />
+<code>|revid='''''Revision ID'''''</code><br />
-<code>|n='''''Status'''''</code><br />
+<code>|copyright='''''Status'''''</code><br />
-<code>|v='''''Status'''''</code><br />
+<code>|newsworthy='''''Status'''''</code><br />
+<code>|verifiable='''''Status'''''</code><br />
 <code>|npov='''''Status'''''</code><br />
-<code>|s='''''Status'''''</code><br />
+<code>|style='''''Status'''''</code><br />
 <code>|reviewer='''''Your Username'''''</code><br />
 <code>|comments='''''Any Comments,''''' <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki></code><br />
 <code>|time=<nowiki>~~~~~}}</nowiki></code>
+'''''Revision ID''''' is the number of the revision that has been reviewed. This is obtained from the History page of an article - it is the number after "''oldid''" in the current revision.
-Where '''''Status''''' is '''''pass''''' for a passed section, or comments for a failed section.
-*'''c''' is for '''Copyright''': The reviewer should check that the text and images are not copyright infringement.
+'''''Status''''' is '''''pass''''' for a passed section, or comments for a failed section.
-*'''n''' is for '''Newsworthiness''': The reviewer should check that the article agrees with our [[Wikinews:Content guide#Write news articles|content guide]] and is newsworthy.
+*'''Copyright''': The reviewer should check that the text and images are not copyright infringement.
-*'''v''' is for '''Verifiability''': The reviewer should check that all information in the article is fully [[Wikinews:Cite sources|sourced]], (using multiple independent sources is strongly encouraged) or has adequate Original Reporting notes.
-*'''npov''' is for '''Neutral Point of View''': The reviewer should check that all information in the article is written in a [[Wikinews:Neutral point of view|neutral and unbiased]] manner, with no editorial commentary/advocacy or unsourced opinion.
+*'''Newsworthiness''': The reviewer should check that the article agrees with our [[Wikinews:Content guide#Write news articles|content guide]] and is newsworthy.
+*'''Verifiability''': The reviewer should check that all information in the article is fully [[Wikinews:Cite sources|sourced]], (using multiple independent sources is strongly encouraged) or has adequate Original Reporting notes.
-*'''s''' is for '''Style''': The reviewer should check that all information in the article complies with our [[Wikinews:Style guide|style guide]] (on [[Wikinews:Style guide#Using the Date and Dateline templates|dateline]], grammar and [[Wikinews:Style guide#Spelling|spelling]], [[Wikinews:Style guide#The first paragraph|"inverted pyramid" structure]], [[Wikinews:Style guide#Writing tone and structure|tone]], [[Wikinews:Style guide#Wiki links within an article|wikilinks]], [[Wikinews:Style guide#Wikinews Categories|categories]], [[Wikinews:Naming conventions|headline]]... etc.)
+*'''Neutral Point of View''': The reviewer should check that all information in the article is written in a [[Wikinews:Neutral point of view|neutral and unbiased]] manner, with no editorial commentary/advocacy or unsourced opinion.
+*'''Style''': The reviewer should check that all information in the article complies with our [[Wikinews:Style guide|style guide]] (on [[Wikinews:Style guide#Using the Date and Dateline templates|dateline]], grammar and [[Wikinews:Style guide#Spelling|spelling]], [[Wikinews:Style guide#The first paragraph|"inverted pyramid" structure]], [[Wikinews:Style guide#Writing tone and structure|tone]], [[Wikinews:Style guide#Wiki links within an article|wikilinks]], [[Wikinews:Style guide#Wikinews Categories|categories]], [[Wikinews:Naming conventions|headline]]... etc.)
 ==Examples==
 '''A Passed article would look like:'''
-<code><nowiki>{{peer reviewed|c=pass|n=pass|v=pass|npov=pass|s=pass|reviewer=Skenmy|comments=A very good article! --~~~~|time=~~~~~}}</nowiki></code>
+<code><nowiki>{{peer reviewed|revid=12345|copyright=pass|newsworthy=pass|verifiable=pass|npov=pass|style=pass|reviewer=Skenmy|comments=A very good article! --~~~~|time=~~~~~}}</nowiki></code>
-{{peer reviewed|c=pass|n=pass|v=pass|npov=pass|s=pass|reviewer=Skenmy|comments=A very good article! --<span style="font-family: Verdana, sans-serif"><strong>[[User:Skenmy|<span style="color:orange;">Sken</span>]]</strong></span>[[User_talk:Skenmy|<span style="color:orange;">my</span> <sup>talk</sup>]] 21:35, 9 August 2008 (UTC)|time=21:35, 9 August 2008 (UTC)}}
+{{peer reviewed|revid=12345|copyright=pass|newsworthy=pass|verifiable=pass|npov=pass|style=pass|reviewer=Skenmy|comments=A very good article! --<span style="font-family: Verdana, sans-serif"><strong>[[User:Skenmy|<span style="color:orange;">Sken</span>]]</strong></span>[[User_talk:Skenmy|<span style="color:orange;">my</span> <sup>talk</sup>]] 21:19, 21 August 2008 (UTC)|time=21:19, 21 August 2008 (UTC)}}
 '''A Failed article would look like:'''
-<code><nowiki>{{peer reviewed|c=pass|n=pass|v=Many of the claims made are not backed up by sources|npov=Appears to be biased|s=pass|reviewer=Skenmy|comments=Otherwise a very good article. --~~~~|time=~~~~~}}</nowiki></code>
+<code><nowiki>{{peer reviewed|revid=12344|copyright=pass|newsworthy=pass|verifiable=Many claims are not backed up by sources|npov=Appears to be biased|style=pass|reviewer=Skenmy|comments=Otherwise a very good article. --~~~~|time=~~~~~}}</nowiki></code>
-{{peer reviewed|c=pass|n=pass|v=Many of the claims made are not backed up by sources|npov=Appears to be biased|s=pass|reviewer=Skenmy|comments=Otherwise a very good article. --<span style="font-family: Verdana, sans-serif"><strong>[[User:Skenmy|<span style="color:orange;">Sken</span>]]</strong></span>[[User_talk:Skenmy|<span style="color:orange;">my</span> <sup>talk</sup>]] 21:35, 9 August 2008 (UTC)|time=21:35, 9 August 2008 (UTC)}}</noinclude>
+{{peer reviewed|revid=12344|copyright=pass|newsworthy=pass|verifiable=Many claims are not backed up by sources|npov=Appears to be biased|style=pass|reviewer=Skenmy|comments=Otherwise a very good article. --<span style="font-family: Verdana, sans-serif"><strong>[[User:Skenmy|<span style="color:orange;">Sken</span>]]</strong></span>[[User_talk:Skenmy|<span style="color:orange;">my</span> <sup>talk</sup>]] 21:19, 21 August 2008 (UTC)|time=21:19, 21 August 2008 (UTC)}}</noinclude>